Jump to Recipe Jump to Video Print Recipe

Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Burnt Cheesecake

Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Burnt Cheesecake! My version of Basque cheesecake, beautifully burnt on a biscuit crust (because we like crust!) topped off with a oh-so-yummy orange chocolate peanut butter ganache & toffee leaf.

I have never made a Basque cheesecake until this Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Burnt Cheesecake.

Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Burnt Cheesecake top view My speckled & golden Basque with crust!

Why? – Because Basque cheesecake is crustless and in my book, the anatomy of a cheesecake always needs crust!

I like the bit of char in a creamy Basque but its countenance? Not always. The rustic Basque burnt mien can be easily overdone in the oven, i.e. super burnt & black with a sunken middle when cooled 😬

Slice of Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Burnt Cheesecake Sweet, salty, zesty & perfectly creamy

But but … what if we bake with biscuit crust and give it a beautiful ganache makeover on top? Think ugly duckling transformed and taking its place in the master race of the gorgeous swan 🤨🤨

If you dare dream it, make it come true! So here it is, the Sugar Crumble’s variation 😊

Transformed Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Burnt Cheesecake Transformed!

Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Burnt Cheesecake! A Basque burnt cheesecake baked atop the usual cookie base and topped off with yummy orange chocolate peanut butter ganache. It turned out super pretty, super creamy and super good! Luxuriously smooth, zesty & refreshing with a lovely char and biscuit crunch!

I made this Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Burnt Cheesecake to celebrate my dearest MIL’s birthday and she loved it!

Do you hear that? Cheesecake is calling! And methinks it’s a runaway success! 🥰🥰

Mama with her birthday cake Happy Mom & Dad … treasures!

Check out the recipe tutorial below and I hope you will enjoy this Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Burnt Cheesecake like we did.

WATCH HOW TO MAKE THIS!

If you like this recipe tutorial and like to see more, subscribe to my YouTube channel here

And if you like this Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Burnt Cheesecake, you may also like these other recipes:

What to watch out for ..

#1 Grease and check your baking tin

Instead I used a 6-inch springform tin with well greased sides for easier un-moulding. If you do not grease the sides of the tin, the process of releasing the cheesecake later on will become a tad more difficult and complicated so do grease the sides well.

Leaky Springform tin Removing charred bits from my leaky springform ..

I used an old springform which had become loose and some of the batter leaked as a result. This is easily resolved if only I had checked. If you are similarly using an old tin where there may be some gaps, wrap the base of the tin tightly with tin foil before baking and this should help to prevent leakage.

#2 Remove the air bubbles

Air bubbles Whisking creates many many bubbles!

For this reason, once the cream cheese is whisked to a smooth consistency and the eggs added, I like to switch to a spatula and mix in the rest by hand. Mixing by hand allows me to remove any air bubbles by gently pressing the cream cheese against the side of the bowl. You will see the batter get smoother and smoother as this gentle hand mixing continues.

Mixing by hand to remove bubbles Mix by hand for this smooth consistency

Sieving the batter and running through with a skewer before baking are also good ways to get rid of air bubbles and any lumps.

Sieve and Skewer Sieve & skewer, whatever it takes for a smooth creamy cheesecake!

Be patient to do this well and you will be rewarded with a beautiful smooth creamy cheesecake.

#3 Orange chocolate peanut butter

One might ask why Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter? Well, inspiration came from a limited edition chocolate orange peanut butter hand delivered by precious dot when she came back from the U.K.

Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Her hand delivered inspiration!

But not to worry if one does not have this limited edition peanut butter. Simple creamy peanut butter will be just as indulgent combined with the fresh orange flavor in this burnt cheesecake. So try and be inspired!

I like to use fresh orange for this Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Burnt Cheesecake because the wonderful zesty flavour comes from the freshly grated orange zest in the ganache.

Use fresh orange Fresh zest .. smells amazing

The fresh zest not only brings out the sweet tart fragrance of the fruit; it also looks amazing when spruced exuberantly on top of the ganache like brilliant gold specks. Freshly squeezed orange and lemon juice added to the softened cheese gives a nice citrus lift to its creaminess, a perfect complement. So don’t skip the fresh orange.

#4 Watch for the wobble

Baking the cheesecake Make sure to check and not over-bake

If the cheesecake is totally firm when baked, it’s overdone. To know how to watch for the wobble, watch the recipe tutorial @5:16 minute.

#5 Flour substitutes

I used rice flour for a gluten free cheesecake. The rice flour can be easily substituted with all purpose flour. Likewise, the corn starch can be replaced with wheat starch.

Adding flour Adding starch minimizes cracking

The small amount of flour helps to give structure and minimizes any cracking that may occur during baking. Using a little flour also gives a lighter texture and balances out the thick creaminess of the cheese.

#6 Un-moulding

Be patient and take care during un-moulding to keep the cheesecake intact and pristine. Use a hot towel and wipe down the sides to slowly disengage the chilled cheesecake from the tin.

Unadorned Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Burnt Cheesecake Easy un-moulded cheesecake .. thru’ the lens of my leaky springform

Alternatively use a hair dryer on low heat to gently blow the sides to help the process. I used a 6-inch round spring form tin which made un-moulding relatively easy. Watch the video @ 6:33 minute for the un-moulding.

#7 Toffee leaf

I crowned this Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Burnt Cheesecake with a melted burnt toffee which was IMHO perfect. I used a Devon toffee melted on low heat and as it melted, part of the toffee burnt giving a beautiful graduated ombré color with a tributary of lines radiating outwards. I simply call it my toffee leaf!

Toffee Leaf Love the burnt ombre & lines

The key to this toffee leaf is to use low heat and to monitor the melting throughout. The toffee did not melt evenly so the part that melted first became more charred, producing that ombré effect.

Once the toffee is completely melted, switch off heat and gently remove with a spatula. If you like, shape it delicately as preferred whilst it’s still soft. The toffee does harden quite quickly, so work fast if you want to play with the shape. More importantly, have fun!

#8 Storage

This Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Burnt Cheesecake is best served chilled the next day after setting in the fridge overnight. It keeps well for 4-5 days, stored airtight and chilled in the refrigerator.

Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Burnt Cheesecake My runaway success 🥰 !

Did you make this? I would love to know how it turned out. Tell me more 😊 Please leave me a comment or tag me on Instagram or Facebook hashtag #thesugarcrumble

Like this? Rate and comment below!

Share your rating, comment, or both.

Print Recipe

Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Burnt Cheesecake

A gorgeous Basque burnt cheesecake filled with orange and peanut butter goodness, baked on a lovely cookie crust and crowned with orange chocolate ganache and a burnt ombré toffee leaf.

Prep Time45

Cook Time30

Chilling4

Total Time5 15

Servings: 6 inch round tin

Author: Kai

Ingredients

Biscuit crust

125 g chocolate chip biscuits
55 g melted butter (unsalted)

Cheesecake layer

250 g cream cheese (softened)
1/3 cup sugar
3 eggs @room temperature
1 tbsp orange juice
1 to 2 tbsp lemon juice
4 tsp rice flour
2 tsp cornstarch
225 ml heavy cream @room temperature
1/2 tsp sea salt
1 tbsp orange chocolate peanut butter or peanut butter for swirling

Orange chocolate peanut butter ganache

1/4 white chocolate chip
1/4 cup peanut butter chips
1/2 cup heavy cream
1/4 tsp salt
1 to 2 tbsp orange zest

Decor

1 Devon toffee (melted)
Strips of orange rind

Instructions

Biscuit base

Blitz the cookies in the blender until you get crumbs. Add the melted butter and mix till wet sand texture. Pour into the baking tin and compact well to form the crust base. Freeze fro 30 minutes.

Cheesecake layer

Whisk cream cheese and sugar till softened and smooth. Whisk eggs and add in two parts to the cream cheese, incorporating well. Switch to a spatula, add in the orange juice and lemon juice and mix gently by hand, removing air bubbles as much as possible by gently pressing the batter against the side of the bowl.
Sieve in the rice flour and corn starch. Mix in till smooth. Sieve the batter through to get a really smooth consistency with minimal air bubbles. Finally add in the heavy cream and salt and mix well. Mix gently by hand until the batter is smooth and silky. Take a few scoops of batter and mix with 1 tbsp of orange chocolate peanut butter (or peanut butter) until well combined and smooth. Dribble in the orange chocolate peanut butter mix into the batter (no need to mix).
Preheat oven for 30min to get it very hot @240C. Line the base and grease the sides of a 6 inch spring form tin, then transfer the batter into the tin. Run through the batter with a skewer to remove air bubbles and to create nice swirls with the peanut butter batter. Tap the tin a few times on the tabletop to remove air bubbles.
Bake @ 240C for 30min. The top will be burnt but the cheesecake should still be slightly jiggly (check the recipe video @5:16 min to see what this looks like). Remove from the oven and cool for 5-10min.

Peanut butter ganache

Microwave the peanut butter chips and white chocolate chips with the heavy cream in 30 sec bursts until melted. Stir till smooth and add in half the orange zest reserving the rest for garnish on top.
Pour in the peanut butter ganache on top of the burnt cheesecake. Garnish with the remaining orange zest and chill in the fridge for 4 hours or overnight to set.

Toffee leaf

Melt a toffee on low heat in a pan, watching carefully as it melts (it usually only takes about a couple of minutes). Some parts could be more charred as the toffee may not melt evenly. Once completely melted, it will be flat like a thin wafer and slightly roundish. Switch off heat and remove gently with a spatula whilst it’s still soft. Set aside to cool completely and the toffee will harden as it cools.

Serving

Once the cheesecake has set, un-mould carefully and if you like, decorate with the burnt toffee leaf (*optional*) and some orange rind strips. Serve chilled and enjoy.

Video

Notes

If you like this recipe tutorial and like to see more, subscribe to my YouTube channel here

#1 Grease and check your baking tin

Unlike the usual Basque cheesecake which is baked in several layers of parchment and has rustic wrinkled sides, I decided to bake my Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Burnt Cheesecake directly in the tin without parchment. Instead I used a 6-inch springform tin with well greased sides for easier un-moulding. If you do not grease the sides of the tin, the process of releasing the cheesecake later on will become a tad more difficult and complicated so do grease the sides well.

#2 Remove the air bubbles

Air bubble is the bane of any creamy cheesecake and they can also cause cracks during baking. Therefore do not over-mix or introduce too much air when whisking the cream cheese and mixing in the ingredients. For this reason, once the cream cheese is whisked to a smooth consistency and the eggs added, I like to switch to a spatula and mix in the rest by hand.

Mixing by hand allows me to remove any air bubbles by gently pressing the cream cheese against the side of the bowl. You will see the batter get smoother and smoother as this gentle hand mixing continues. Sieving the batter and running through with a skewer before baking are also good ways to get rid of air bubbles and any lumps. Be patient to do this well and you will be rewarded with a beautiful smooth creamy cheesecake.

#3 Orange chocolate peanut butter

One might ask why Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter? Well, inspiration came from a limited edition orange chocolate peanut butter hand delivered by dot when she came back from the U.K.

I like to use fresh orange for this Orange Chocolate Peanut Butter Burnt Cheesecake because the wonderful zesty flavor comes from the freshly grated orange zest in the ganache.

#4 Watch for the wobble

Always check the cheesecake as it bakes so that it’s not overdone (I usually check around the 20-25 minute mark). The cheesecake should be nicely burnt but still with a little wobble when it’s done which should set nicely after it is cooled and chilled. If the cheesecake is totally firm when baked, it’s overdone. To know how to watch for the wobble, watch the recipe tutorial @5:16 minute.

#5 Flour substitutes

I used rice flour for a gluten free cheesecake. The rice flour can be easily substituted with all purpose flour. Likewise, the corn starch can be replaced with wheat starch. The small amount of flour helps to give structure and minimizes any cracking that may occur during baking. Using a little flour also gives a lighter texture and balances out the thick creaminess of the cheese.

#6 Un-moulding

Be patient and take care during un-moulding to keep the cheesecake intact and pristine. Use a hot towel and wipe down the sides to slowly disengage the chilled cheesecake from the tin.

#7 Toffee leaf

The key to this toffee leaf is to use low heat and to monitor the melting throughout. The toffee did not melt evenly so the part that melted first became more charred, producing that ombré effect. Once the toffee is completely melted, switch off heat and gently remove with a spatula. If you like, shape it delicately as preferred whilst it’s still soft. The toffee does harden quite quickly, so work fast if you want to play with the shape. More importantly, have fun!

#8 Storage